Ather also tested their initial mules in Meeco Kartopia and so is Simple energy. This video says simple energy factory will be in Whitefield. I wonder if they have occupied the same factory premises of Ather? .
Overall scooter looks smaller than Ather but the floorboard is thicker I guess. If their range claim is close to reality, Ather’s sale numbers can be affected…atleast in Bengaluru.
Going to make this a very knees high sort of position.
Still not big enough for a battery that can give 240Km of range. Even considering 20Wh/Km which is highly unlikely, it would be a 4.8kWh battery pack.
And the arai range was 240Km for mark1 so idk how they’re doing it.
You’ll need to navigate through a few dicey links that have spam links overlaid on them, but you will finally reach this page. I think the above link is from there:
A couple of things struck me when I read the article on them:
The first prototype that we developed had a 200 km range in Eco mode, which is between 30-40 kmph speed
If they can actually give 200 km range at 40 kmph, that’s truly incredible. But can they, with existing tech within reasonable costs? Curious to know how they achieved the seemingly impossible.
Suhas Rajkumar, Founder & CEO, Simple Energy: The Ather 450X is our primary competition. What Ather Energy has done is absolutely amazing, there’s no doubt about that.
My hunch is that they aspire to have their pricing pegged somewhere in the vicinity of Ather 450 / 450 Plus very likely. Their primary intention would be to just give enough incentive to dislodge the potential target audience of Ather 450X, if at all their economics allows them to.
Also, on a different note, if we all thought the Ather seat was a literal pain in the arse to use, then check out the incline on this thing (that of the pillion section is quite a bit too)!
They might be able to. For reference. These Chinese EVs and even Pure EV gives a 2.5kWh battery pack at 80k and some 2.8 kWh at under 1 lakh. The Benlng Aura is a relatively goof scooter at 1 Lakh. 2.8kWh will give 100+Km
Simple might have packed a 4kWh battery at 1.4lakhs. I think it could be split. Some in the floor. Some part under the seat. Only way they can do it. The only problem I see is, the motor. When these EVs are priced low with high range, they tend to have a very under powered motor. So they must have done some cost cutting somewhere. Just have to see where it is.
I would choose more range over smart. What about the rest of you
Which would you choose
Smart scooter normal range, high performance- 450X
More range, no connected features, not smart , average ride mode performance
Correct! And that is what is surprising. Most companies try to cut down on costs by sourcing components from China. But SE claims that they have developed everything inhouse or sourced locally (except the cells). So yeah, there is some component that is going to drop the ball somewhere. We’ll know only on launch I guess.
Simple energy has revealed that the name of their first scooter will be “Simple One”. It will be launched on August 15th in Bengaluru, Chennai, and Hyderabad followed by other cities in months to come. It will have a 4.8 kWh battery and 240 km of range in ECO mode.
I think with such a big battery it can give 150 km of real-world range in ECO mode.
Simple One is S1 and Series One is S1. Will get confusing for reviewers while writing a comparison review. But good thing is that Series One will not be available in the long run.
From, whatever we’ve seen of the shape of the scooter, and the battery capacity, I’m really interested to see the weight distribution and the way it’d handle.
Top speed of 100 KMPH!!! That’s interesting. I am assuming this to be again a completely software controlled vehicle. Is it going to have a similar buggy software or other issues, that we will need to see. But honestly i didnt like the way it looks, especially the handle. Ather anyday wins.
Will check it out as I am planning to sell my Series 1 soon. Unfortunately this is not coming to Delhi anytime soon so will check it out on my trip to Bengaluru after its launch.