** The scooter has an ICAT-certified range of 116 km per full charge, which is the highest in the country in this particular class of product, and comes with patented battery technology.**
This IIT-Hyderabad incubated startup is all set to ride the EV high on its newly launched electric scooter.
All electric bikes come under one category of range. This bike runs 60kmh top speed. But Ather is different breed of EV bike. It gives run for fast running bike in market.
Bro compare the price to features. Do you think the price justifies for Ather(Rs 159000/- ex.Showroom) when we compare with some similar EVās like Pluto (79,999 (ex-showroom)). Pluto has more range, Ather has more acceleration.
Choosing bike has many parameter for buyers. If we count on money Okinawa is lesser in price and range is 200kms. Buying definitely goes on parameters like Made-India for some/ highest range/ looks of bike. Only the consistent one remain in market.
Letās compare the best with the second best, what ever be it according to you. At some point the price must also be taken in to consideration as it will be the deciding factor for many as we cannot just ignore the point that Ather is overpriced when compared to its best market peersā¦
You just canāt compare epluto7g and Ather 450ā¦let alone 450x. Itās just too unfair on the epluto7g. There is just no comparison at all.
Take a look at the specs
Parameter
ePluto7G
450
450X
Battery
2.5kwh
2.7kwh
2.9kwh
Cells
18650
18650
21700
Peak power
2kw
5.4kw
6kw
Torque
NA
20Nm
26Nm
Top speed
60kmph
80kmph
80kmph
Tyres
10"
12"
12"
Brakes
F-Disc R-Drum
F-Disc R-Disc
F-Disc R-Disc
ARAI/ICAT Range
116kms
107kms
116kms
Gradeability
12Ā°
18Ā°
18Ā°
0-40kmph
5s
3.9s
3.3s
weight
80kilos
118kgs
108kgs
Battery Warranty
40000kms
Unlimited Kms
Unlimited Kms
Dashboard
MF LCD
Touchscreen LCD with Navigation
Android touchscreen LCD with Navigation
IP rating
IP65
IP67
IP67
Storage
NA no full size helmet
22Ltrs Full size helmet
22Ltrs Full size helmet
Fast Charging
No
Yes
Yes
Connectivity
NA
3G
4G, Bluetooth, Wifi
Back in 2016, we purchased Alto K10 AMT for my wife and Polo GTTSI for myself together on the same day. GTTSI costed 11lakhs and K10 costed 5Lakhs. One of my colleague told while pulling my legā¦āYour GTTSI is so overpriced. you got fooled. compare with your wifeās alto. Both are hatchbacks, Both run on Petrol, Both have AT, Both can seat 4 people comfortably and 5 with a squeeze, Alto gives higher mileage, GTTSI may just have a higher top speed thatās all, Alto is from a much older brand in India, both have music system (who cares about touchscreen)ā I agreed to every point of his but we all know the reality of why one costs 11L and the other costs 5L.
Iāve drawn this analogy before too because I own and know the vehicles well. It is a repetition but the message Iām trying to convey is that we should not compare every electric scooter to every other electric scooter. There are different segments now (which wasnāt heard of earlier). The closest competitor for the 450x is the Chetak so far. Chetak is a good scooter but Even there the 40-50k premium that the 450x demands is worth it IMO.
If this epluto7g can demand 80000, then the 450x can certainly demand 159000. Iāll buy a petrol scooter if I cannot afford more than 80000.
I wouldnāt compare Chetak and the 450. As per your analogy, they are still different segments. iQube maybe is a better comparison similar range and top speed and a 0.4-0.5 second difference in acceleration. Chetak of course is well built and all but Ather still sits in itās own niche just like your GT TSI.
I tired the EPluto 7G at their Kalmassery/Kochi showroom. This was a classic looking, dumb E scooter, with a few not-so-dumb features.
Comparison:
Positives:
Higher (claimed) range.
Silent driving
Car-style RKE system with immobilizer and alarm (yes back tire wonāt budge!)
Removable battery. Can charge indoors, carry two packs for long trips, etc
Smaller charging unit
Center stand
Pillion side footrest
Price < 1L
Negatives:
No connected features
Hub drive, affects driving feel hugely
Limits 65 kmph for sport mode (top speed)
Very little seating space
Almost no boot space because battery is in the boot
(this is huge) accelerator will not work if you touch brakes
About the accelerator-brake issue: My wife and I were testing and on a u-turn slope. We had to brake and accelerate together to get out of that situation and it was impossible. I had to get in and use clutch-brake-accelerator skills like in driving a car to get back moving! If this was a main road, you get really busted!
Overall, getting the Ather 450x was worth the money, when compared to the half-priced EPluto 7G.
Plus it sort of cuts off if you hit a huge pothole. Probably something to do with the hub motor torque rather than the throttle.
The epluto is good for its own market. Many fruit vendors and shop owners around my aread have bought it and theyāre real happpy. They get 70-80+Km range adn at the fraction of the cost of petrol. Power isnāt a necessity for them. It rides at the speed theyād normally ride an activa.
I look at the 80 Kilos and Im always surprised. Itās so light weight! It must be super efficient.
I bet there is history of ICE engines exploding like this, way back when they were introduced. But still they caught up due to necessity. But ePluto gets a lot of minus points on this, like Okinawa.
And this incident will be used as generalized shaming of all EVs.
Company should apologise and take responsibility of it, itās loss of trust of many.
this video is going around social media. what was the problem?
Itās EV Pluto 7g, but how guaranty you can give for our Ather 450 X or 450ā¦ please donāt delete this post. we want the answer. all need to know.
We canāt possibly comment on why that particular scooter caught fire, but have passed this on to the battery team to get back on some of our testing and safety measures to prevent such issues with the 450/450 Plus/450X battery packs.
Still, we feel you have to know the reason and see it wonāt happenā¦ no EV is perfect. we still fear to ride. donāt see Ather video viral in the coming days. this is just to give you caution and clear it out our doubts, many many of my friends are asking me and all the EV owners in Ather community that why will it not happen to yours or any other company EV. please R&D.